On a beautiful day by the ocean, Paul the blue penguin and his best friend Tommy the turtle are gathering food for the season. All of a sudden, Paul gets a whiff of an unfamiliar fish smell. Following the smell, Paul and Tommy embark on an adventure that leads them into a nearby Jewish community. There they discover gefilte fish and help themselves to the treat. Back home, the two friends realize they are in trouble and work together to right their wrongs. Join Paul and Tommy as they learn about Passover traditions and the power of apologizing.